Review: Narrative Clip wearable lifelogging camera
The device is relatively small and inconspicuous
In October 2012, a device called Memoto
raised its Kickstarter goal of US$50,000 in under 5 hours and went on
to raise over $550,000. Memoto went into production and began shipping
in November 2013. Now called Narrative Clip, the device is a wearable
lifelogging camera and a smash Kickstarter success. But is it any good? Ashacks got the opportunity to find out.
The first thing to address about Narrative Clip is the premise. It is
designed to be clipped onto clothing or placed standing up somewhere
and it takes a photo every 30 seconds. If the lens is visible, it is
taking photos. To turn the device off, users need only place it face
down on a surface.
Although, by way of digital cameras, social media and the Facebook
Paparazzi, we've become more comfortable with being constantly captured
on camera, some people may find the passive and automatic nature of the
Narrative Clip unnerving. There can be a sense that it's another device
chipping away at our privacy.
Others view it as a clever means of capturing photos that they may
otherwise have missed and capturing candid moments in their lives
without the conspicuous intrusion of a manual camera. There are merits
to both points, but for the benefit of this review we'll leave the
conundrums about morality and usefulness to you, instead focusing how
well the device achieves what it sets out to do.
Our Narrative Clip turned up in clean white packaging reminiscent of
that used by Apple. The contents of the box were refreshingly sparse,
with just a short USB cable, a manual and the camera itself. Users are
directed to the set up website where the required software can be
downloaded and the device can be registered. Users are also asked to
download the smartphone app for iOS or Android. There is a genuine sense
of simplicity about the whole process, it feels like it's been
thoughtfully considered.
Indeed, rarely does a manual warrant comment in a review, but its
short, image-based content furthers the sense of ease with which the
device is delivered and intended to be used. It all helps to set the
user at rest with a type of device that it's unlikely they will have
used before.
The device itself is a lovely, understated piece of design. At 36 x
36 x 9 mm (1.42 x 1.42 x 0.35 in), it's small enough to be relatively
unnoticeable when worn, but not so small as to be easily mislaid. Our
device was white, although orange and gray are also available, with a
black back-plate and a sturdy silver clip. The camera lens sits at the
bottom front corner and the only two other features of note are a set of
four LED lights along one side used for indicating battery status and
photo activity, and a USB port that is covered by a sliver of black
plastic (which can be a touch fiddly). There's no more to the device
than is necessary and, noticeably, no buttons. To take a photo manually
users need only double-tap it.
Fully charging the Narrative Clip for the first time took about an
hour and a half, after which it was ready to go. I slid it onto my
jacket lapel and went to get some lunch. I wore it to a gig and to work.
There's a degree of self-consciousness wearing the device for the first
time, but people in the street didn't seem to notice it. It's when you
begin chatting to someone that they become aware of the device, which
may prompt a conversation about what it is. People can naturally be a
bit uncomfortable about being constantly photographed and it should go
without saying that there are times to put the camera away in your
pocket (which will put it into sleep mode).
The Narrative Clip uses a USB connection to upload images to the
company's servers using a computer's Internet connection and, if the
user wants, copy images to their computer's storage. There is no
automatic wireless uploading, which is a shame, but understandable given
the battery drain that the functionality would be. Unfortunately, my
first photos were not immediately forthcoming. Narrative had experienced
some problems "creating Moments" (as it calls the photo collections)
and the opportunity to view my photos was delayed.
When I did get to view my photos, a number of things became apparent.
Firstly, the camera isn't great. Narrative says it's as good as a
smartphone camera, but in my opinion it's not quite at that level.
Photos blur easily and are grainy in low light. This is perhaps to be
expected, it's a small, limited device and the serendipitous approach to
taking photos will naturally result in a lot of dross, with the
occasional gem. I could live with that and it's definitely the case, as
with any camera, that the more you use the device, the more you'll learn
how to get better photos with it.
Depending on how you've been wearing the device, photos are also on
one strange angle or another. This is corrected automatically when the
photos are uploaded to the Narrative app, but not in photos that are
copied to the user's computer.
You'd think, therefore, that the processed images might be
downloadable from the Narrative servers, but after much searching it
occurred to me that there is no means of viewing images on the Web, only
via smartphone app. This is a huge miss. Narrative says you can share
images via the app, but it doesn't provide any means of editing images.
The inability to get your hands on the processed photos seems like an
oversight at best, or consciously obstructive at worst.
Everything that happened (or didn't) after connecting the device to a
computer felt like a bit of a let down. An afterthought even. The
uploading software is limited and could easily have an editor/organizer
built into it. Photos pulled directly from the device to a user's
computer are left for the user to deal with themselves if they want to
do any editing. Loading photos on the app, meanwhile, is slow and
functionality is limited. Users can view sets of photos by scrolling
through or via a slideshow. Photos can be deleted, marked as favorites,
set as key images in the series or shared, but that's about it.
The lack of a desktop experience feels too restrictive for a device
that costs what the Narrative Clip does, which brings me nicely onto
that point. As I was showing the device to some friends, I asked what
they thought of it. There was a feeling that it was a nice idea and that
it would be a good stocking filler. A bit of a novelty that might be
useful every so often. Price-wise they thought maybe £30-£60 ($50-$100).
I'm inclined to agree with most of that, though perhaps I'd nudge the
price up a touch. The Narrative Clip retails for $279 (£167) though.
That feels a bit steep for a camera that produces photos that are so-so
at best, and then limits your access to them afterwards.
The Narrative Clip is a good concept. The execution is excellent in
some aspects, but feels drastically lacking in others. Either the price
needs to come down, or the quality and functionality need to go up.
